London Assembly says Property Guardians are 'second-class renters'.

The report raises issues of the rights a property guardian has when they enter into such an agreement and describes the guardians as ‘second-class renters’.

The industry of property guardians is billed as a win-win. A property owner, rents out his property to a guardian at sub-standard market rates; often to avoid taxes on leaving a building empty.

In turn, this arrangement is set up by a property guardian company, who gain a nice commission.

However, the report highlights a growing trend in the industry of ‘legal grey’ areas, which some say are being exploited by the property guardian companies.

Guardian: ‘I’ve had a number of legal issues’

Rex Duis, a property guardian based in Hammersmith and Fulham gave an exclusive interview to City News:

‘My experience as a property guardian has been mixed, I’ve had good and bad experiences but I’ve been in it for a long time now. As a property guardian, I’ve had a number of legal issues, usually it was because the agency has broken terms with their own contracts and I decided to fight them over that.’

Duis went on: ‘ When signing up as a property guardian you should have 28 days notice, that’s what you’re legally entitled to, however it hasn’t always been the case. I have personally experienced guardian companies kick me out in less than 28 days.’

Lawyer: ‘No legal definition of ‘property guardian’

The legal grey areas mentioned by Duis are an area for reform, according to the London Assembly and Andrew Dymond, a lawyer who has contributed to a white paper on property guardian law:

There is no legal definition of a “Property Guardian”. Usually, the agreement between the Guardian Company and the Guardian will be called a “licence” rather than a “tenancy”, the significance being that tenants have more rights than licensees, in particular with regard to eviction.’

Camelot: ‘We would like to see more regulation’

However, it is not just guardians and lawyers who want to see reform.

Paul Lloyd, operations manager for Camelot, a property guardian company, said: ‘Yes we would like to see regulation come in from outside about and be implemented across the board’.